All Documents

The complete indexed collection for the selected era.

Searches the one-sentence summaries and document metadata.
Production: digits or an SC_* ID. FOIA: hyphens are optional.
Era 1 Era 2 All
Page 138 of 344 — 34,377 documents
PDF documents by FOIA ID
2025-EPA-04193 1
BLM201700947 29
BLM201800232 8
BLM201800355 6
BLM201800412 165
BLMAK201800695 84
EPA-HQ-2017-008402 13,030
FS2017FSWO04297 62
FS2017FSWO04301 21
FS2017FSWO057670577306859 38
FSWO201706591 51
FSWO201706593 39
HQ2017008402 1,927
HQ2017008402716 171
OS201700602 225
No FOIA ID assigned 18,520
Summary Year FOIA ID Number Production ID Pages
The email from William Wehrum expresses gratitude for assistance in coordinating a Capitol tour for his family, with Troy Lyons from the EPA facilitating the arrangements. 2017
ED_002061_00130628
Troy Lyons
1
The email correspondence involves the EPA's Sydney Hupp coordinating a meeting with Maxim Pasik to discuss WaterGen, with logistics assistance from Cheryl Woodward. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The email correspondence involves EPA officials coordinating a meeting with William Wehrum regarding the Sierra Club v. EPA case. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 1
The document outlines the itinerary for an EPA delegation visit to Melbourne, Australia, including meetings, media arrangements, and potential locations for discussions on environmental topics. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email correspondence between Sydney Hupp of the EPA and Shawn Bennett of the Ohio Oil & Gas Association discusses scheduling updates for Administrator Pruitt's calendar, particularly regarding events in September and travel plans. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 6
Rick Smith urges the EPA to change the Renewable Fuel Standard's point of obligation to protect jobs at independent refiners, highlighting the unfair burden placed on them compared to larger companies. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 1
The email from Hayley Ford of the EPA confirms a meeting with Tea Party Patriots at the White House regarding topics such as tax reform and healthcare, requesting additional details about the event. 2017
ED_002061_00064383
Tate Bennett
4
The email correspondence between Iowa official Stephanie Groen and EPA Senior Advisor Don Benton discusses scheduling a meeting for Governors from Iowa, Nebraska, Indiana, and Minnesota with Administrator Pruitt on February 24, 2017. 2017
ED_002061_00111319
Michelle Hale
4
The document outlines the administrative schedule for Florida Governor Rick Scott and Lieutenant Governor Carlos Lopez-Cantera for October 17, 2017, including a cabinet meeting and meetings with state economic officials. 2017
ED_002061_00009503
Michael Abboud
1
The email discusses the upcoming committee votes on four energy nominees by the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, highlighting concerns over David Bernhardt's nomination due to his industry ties and ethical questions, as well as the expected support from Republicans for the other nominees. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 13
Scott Cameron from the Office of the Secretary of the Interior informed Josh Abel from the Association of California Water Agencies that he cannot participate in a panel discussion scheduled for March 1, 2017, due to a scheduling conflict. 2017 2
The email correspondence from the EPA discusses scheduling conflicts regarding Administrator Pruitt's potential keynote speech at a May 3, 2017 event related to the first 100 days of the Trump Administration. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 9
The document is a letter from Congressman Bill Johnson supporting Andrew Wheeler's nomination as Deputy Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), highlighting his qualifications and experience in environmental policy. 2017
ED_002061_00169680
Kaitlyn Shimmin
1
The email exchange between Sydney Hupp of the EPA and Jeff Reamy discusses scheduling a meeting for mid-June, accommodating Larry Ziemba's travel plans, and confirming availability amidst potential testimony preparation. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The document is an administrative schedule from the Governor's Press Office detailing Governor Scott and Lt. Governor Lopez-Cantera's appointments for September 27, 2017, including discussions on disaster assistance related to Puerto Rico recovery. 2017
ED_002061_00010639
Michael Abboud
1
The email from Rick Shelby of Capitol Hill Consulting Group to Ryan Jackson at the EPA discusses scheduling a meeting with President Hargis during the narrow time frame of October 4-5, 2017. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 1
Catherine Cromer from the Tennessee government is coordinating with Tate Bennett from the EPA regarding an upcoming roundtable event, seeking a list of attendees and discussing the agenda. 2017
ED_002061_00062196
Tate Bennett
1
The email exchange between Troy Lyons of the EPA and William Koetzle of Chevron discusses scheduling a meeting to catch up over coffee and includes a suggestion to consider getting the EPA Administrator offshore. 2017
ED_002061_00140618
Troy Lyons
3
The email from Nancy Beck at the EPA discusses scheduling a meeting with DuPont representatives to talk about experiences with the new chemicals program under TSCA Section 5. 2017
ED_002061_00050609
Nancy Beck
2
The Florida Governor's Press Office announced that Governor Rick Scott will meet with local officials in the Florida Keys to discuss Hurricane Irma recovery efforts, with meetings scheduled for September 16, 2017. 2017
ED_002061_00010755
Michael Abboud
1
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced on June 12, 2017, that it is extending the effective date of the Risk Management Program (RMP) Amendments to February 19, 2019, to allow for further review and consideration of public comments and concerns. 2017
ED_002061_00157337
Aaron Ringel
3
The email correspondence between EPA officials discusses scheduling a phone call regarding a speaker request form, with adjustments made to the timing due to conflicts in availability. 2017 5
The email exchange between Albert Kelly of the EPA and Rich Gold of Holland & Knight discusses scheduling a meeting to address EPA comments on the draft Work Plan (WP) and Statement of Work (SOW) related to baseline sampling. 2017
ED_002061_00116758
Albert Kelly
4
The email exchange between Tate Bennett from the EPA and Matt Miltenberger from Nebraska discusses scheduling a call with staff, noting a conflict with the Governor's press conference. 2017
ED_002061_00077303
Tate Bennett
2
The email from Quin Shea of the Edison Electric Institute requests a meeting with Bill Wehrum to discuss environmental issues and enhance the relationship between their organizations following a recent committee meeting. 2017
ED_002061_00183853
Bill Wehrum
1
The letter from various agricultural associations to EPA Administrator E. Scott Pruitt expresses gratitude for a meeting discussing environmental issues affecting production agriculture and offers support for his approach to the agency. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 1
The email from Candice D. Austin of the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) to the EPA's scheduling team is a follow-up regarding a speaker request for Administrator Pruitt to attend NAM's Manufacturing Summit. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email correspondence between EPA officials and Rafael Mangual from the Manhattan Institute discusses arrangements for an upcoming event, including a speaking request for Administrator Pruitt and feedback on an event invitation draft. 2017 5
The EPA's Energy and Climate Report from October 11, 2017, discusses various energy-related topics, including proposed changes to accounting for land easements affecting pipeline companies, ongoing legal challenges to the Clean Power Plan, and developments regarding the Dakota Access Pipeline and NAFTA negotiations on energy issues. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The email from Tate Bennett of the EPA discusses a follow-up meeting arrangement with representatives from the American Seed Trade Association (ASTA) after an introductory meeting with Administrator Pruitt's team. 2017
ED_002061_00076686
Tate Bennett
1
The email correspondence between Brian C. Mormino from Cummins and Sydney Hupp from the EPA discusses rescheduling a meeting with commercial vehicle manufacturers originally planned for April 19 to a later date in May due to scheduling conflicts. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) is discussing a proposed approach to streamline the identification of regulations affecting energy development during land use planning by referencing the land use planning handbook, as indicated in an email from Deputy Assistant Director Karen Kelleher. 2017 BLM201800412 11
The email correspondence involves Millan Hupp from the EPA's Office of the Administrator coordinating with John Sullivan regarding Administrator Pruitt's scheduled speech at the Williams Board Meeting. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email from Samantha Dravis at the EPA discusses a court ruling in the case Sierra Club v. EPA, highlighting a decision that favors the Trump administration regarding the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB). 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
Warren S. Payne from Mayer Brown LLP is requesting assistance from Ryan Jackson at the EPA to arrange a meeting regarding updating the definition of hazardous waste under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, in light of a letter from Secretary Tillerson. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email correspondence involves Ryan Jackson, Chief of Staff at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, coordinating a meeting with Beth White for the following day at 3:30 PM. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 1
The EPA's Daily Environment Report for August 9, 2017, discusses various environmental topics, including judicial guidance for reviving a ban on chemical coolants, the Trump administration's stance on a climate study, and significant pollution crackdowns in China. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 4
The email from Dave Flannery to Mandy Gunasekara at the EPA discusses the Midwest Ozone Group's request for a meeting with Administrator Pruitt to address their Petition for Administrative Reconsideration of the CSAPR Update and Regulatory Reform comments, highlighting concerns about the modeling and implementation of ozone NAAQS. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email from Jason Sloan invites EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt to present at the Association of Air Pollution Control Agencies' 2018 Spring Meeting in Lexington, Kentucky, highlighting the importance of EPA engagement with state and local air quality agencies on Clean Air Act issues. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The email from Cheryl Woodward of the EPA provides logistical details for an upcoming meeting with Maxim Pasik on March 29, 2017, including directions to the building and security procedures. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The email correspondence between Sydney Hupp of the EPA and Scott Smith discusses the potential for the EPA Administrator to speak at a Commerce Lexington event in Washington, D.C., planned for mid-July 2017. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The email from Lee Forsgren at the EPA confirms receipt and approval of a signed letter from Houston regarding the Texas Water Development Board (TWDB). 2017
ED_002061_00099251
Lee Forsgren
1
The email correspondence between Moya Phelleps and Millan Hupp discusses logistical arrangements for Administrator Pruitt's visit, including hotel room reservations and scheduling a meeting with the Executive Committee at the EPA. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email from Richard Slucher of IHS Markit invites EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt to speak at CERAWeek 2018, scheduled for March 5-9, 2018, in Houston, Texas. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The email exchange between Steve Mona of the World Golf Foundation and Samantha Dravis of the EPA discusses the golf industry's interest in the repeal of the Clean Water Rule and the development of a new rule that promotes state/federal cooperation for environmental protection. 2017 HQ2017008402 2
The email correspondence between Justin Schwab and Brian Reeve discusses a meeting related to the CLA Law Committee, with Reeve expressing appreciation for the opportunity to share insights, indicating collaboration between Syngenta Crop Protection and the EPA. 2017
ED_002061_00165330
Justin Schwab
1
The email from Jay Robinovitz to Samantha Dravis and Albert Kelly discusses the completion of a Superfund site closure in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and expresses gratitude for Dravis's insights during a presentation to the Institute of Scrap Recycling group. 2017 HQ2017008402 2
The email exchange between EPA officials discusses logistical concerns regarding an upcoming event featuring a conversation with Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, including timing, crowd control, and the potential for protests. 2017 6
The email exchange between Anne Korin and Samantha Dravis of the EPA discusses the cancellation of a meeting and the preparation of a memo on how fuel choice could contribute to CAFE reform and align with the President's goals. 2017 HQ2017008402 1
The email correspondence involves the EPA and SBA discussing a meeting on March 29, 2017, regarding SBREFA panels and regulatory development related to hard rock mining, with attendees confirmed as Samantha Dravis and Brittany Bolen. 2017 HQ2017008402 2
The EPA plans to take steps to replace the Clean Power Plan by early October 2017, following pressure from electric company executives, despite initial reluctance from Administrator Scott Pruitt. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 6
The email from Darrin Munoz to Ryan Jackson at the EPA discusses the urgency for the agency to issue a policy statement supporting the carbon neutrality of forest byproducts used for electricity production, as requested by International Paper and its trade association, before the legislative language expires at the end of September 2017. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 1
The email from Ryan Jackson at the EPA discusses a New Republic article related to the Sierra Club v. EPA case, indicating ongoing communication about environmental strategy and legal matters. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The email correspondence between Sydney Hupp of the EPA and Lindsay Hoefer of the Family Research Council discusses scheduling a phone call between EPA Administrator Pruitt and Tony Perkins to discuss gathering business leaders in support of Pruitt's leadership. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The email correspondence from the EPA's Office of the Administrator discusses scheduling a meeting on April 5, 2017, between Administrator Pruitt and CEMEX executives, with logistical details being confirmed by Sydney Hupp and James O'Keeffe. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email from MaryAnne Dunlap of Sanofi to Ryan Jackson at the EPA discusses concerns regarding the proposed "Management Standards for Hazardous Waste Pharmaceuticals," arguing that the rule is not cost-effective and adds unnecessary regulatory burdens to an already tightly controlled pharmaceutical distribution system. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The email from Edward Calabrese to Ryan Jackson at the EPA discusses comments on the NRC's consideration of replacing the linear no-threshold (LNT) model with the hormesis model in cancer risk assessment, highlighting the implications for the EPA's approach to cancer risk evaluation. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 12
The email from Cheryl Woodward at the EPA provides logistical details for an upcoming meeting with the American Forest & Paper Association on May 4, 2017, including directions to the EPA building and security procedures. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 14
The email correspondence between Jay Martin of Contura Energy and Sydney Hupp from the EPA's Office of the Administrator discusses scheduling a meeting for Contura Energy's CEO, Kevin Crutchfield, with Administrator Pruitt, initially requested for May 3-4, but later suggested for May 2 due to scheduling conflicts. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The email from William Wehrum to Aaron Ringel discusses the imminent nomination process related to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, with Ringel indicating that confirmation could occur "literally any day." 2017
ED_002061_00156514
Aaron Ringel
1
The email correspondence between Ryan Jackson of the EPA and George D. Baker discusses scheduling a meeting to prepare for a June 19 sit-down regarding utility group recommendations for Administrator Pruitt. 2017 HQ2017008402 3
The EPA's EHS State Regulatory Alert from October 23, 2017, details regulatory updates including Indiana's emergency rule redesignating Lawrenceburg Township as in attainment of the 2008 ozone standard and Louisiana's proposed rule prohibiting the commercial harvest of female blue crabs during March and April of 2018 and 2019. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The email correspondence involves Amy Chiang from Honeywell coordinating a meeting with EPA Administrator Pruitt on June 28, 2017, which was rescheduled to 8:45 AM due to a conflict with a White House appointment. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 8
The email from Jahan Wilcox of the North Dakota government discusses the preparation of a sample invite list for an event on August 10, including key stakeholders involved in the fight against the Waters of the United States (WOTUS) regulation. 2017
ED_002061_00066372
Tate Bennett
2
The email correspondence between Charles Munoz of the Environmental Protection Agency and Henry Darwin discusses logistics for fingerprinting related to new team members joining the agency, with a focus on coordinating the meeting location and confirming readiness at the Ada office. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 1
The email discusses Alcoa's request to the EPA to accept an alternative modeling approach for sulfur dioxide compliance at the Warrick Generating Station, as Region V intends to designate Warrick County as non-attainment based on outdated data. 2017
ED_002061_00065461
Tate Bennett
1
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) communicated the launch of a new research initiative in partnership with Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center to investigate the biology of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS). 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 5
The email from John Bachmann to Samantha Dravis and others discusses the acceptance of Dravis's article for publication in the September 2017 issue of EM Magazine by the EPA, outlining the need for potential revisions based on reviewer feedback and a submission deadline of July 31, 2017. 2017 HQ2017008402 2
The email from Ryan Jackson at the EPA to Robert Nolan at ExxonMobil discusses the operational status of refineries in Texas and Louisiana during Hurricane Harvey, highlighting adjustments due to the closure of the Houston Ship Channel and the prioritization of fuel supply for emergency responders. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The email from Tate Bennett at the EPA requests contact information for the Bateman family in North Dakota to conduct an informal survey on dicamba for the Administrator. 2017
ED_002061_00076157
Tate Bennett
1
The email from Ryan Jackson at the EPA promotes a Government Cybersecurity Workshop on July 12, 2017, organized by Potomac Forum to educate government executives on implementing the President's Cybersecurity Executive Order. 2017 HQ2017008402 5
The National Rural Water Association is partnering with the U.S. Department of Labor to launch a nationwide WaterPro Apprenticeship Program, with a ceremonial signing scheduled for November 14, 2017, to establish a nationally-recognized standard for water sector apprenticeships. 2017
ED_002061_00098285
Lee Forsgren
2
The email correspondence between Sydney Hupp of the EPA and Lindsay Hoefer discusses scheduling a phone call for Tony Perkins to initiate a meeting with key business owners and Administrator Pruitt. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 11
The email exchange involves Mandy Gunasekara from the EPA connecting Frederick Eames with Richard Yamada, the Deputy in the Office of Research and Development, regarding potential applicants for the Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC). 2017
ED_002061_00270333
1 Tier
1
The email correspondence between Aurelia Skipwith, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Fish and Wildlife and Parks at the U.S. Department of the Interior, and Roger Martella from GE Corporate discusses scheduling a call or visit regarding the Hudson River Dredging Project. 2017 4
The emails between Kathy Steckelberg of the Edison Electric Institute and Ryan Jackson, Chief of Staff at the U.S. EPA, discuss scheduling a meeting for July 19, 2017, and coordinating efforts for an upcoming event. 2017 HQ2017008402 2
The EPA was informed by Dennis Deziel that the merger between The Dow Chemical Company and DuPont was successfully completed on August 31, 2017, with plans to separate into three independent companies within 18 months. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 7
The email exchange involves Elizabeth Rosenberg coordinating with EPA officials, including Samantha Dravis, regarding participation in an event discussing the U.S. administration's climate agenda following the decision to exit the Paris Agreement. 2017 HQ2017008402 2
The email exchange between Millan Hupp, Director of Scheduling at the EPA, and Kelly Kundinger discusses arranging a meeting to continue their conversation, highlighting their busy schedules and confirming availability for a coffee meeting. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email correspondence between Millan Hupp of the EPA and Ray Shepherd of Peabody Energy discusses scheduling a potential meeting between Peabody's CEO and Administrator Pruitt. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email correspondence between EPA officials and Oklahoma state representatives discusses the scheduling of a meeting involving Administrator Pruitt, Governor Fallin, and other state officials, confirming attendance and logistics for the event. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 11
The Florida Governor's Press Office released a statement detailing Governor Rick Scott's tour of Hurricane Irma's impacts in St. Johns County, highlighting ongoing response and recovery efforts across the state. 2017
ED_002061_00011119
Michael Abboud
1
The email from Mary Ellen Temes to EPA officials discusses the American College of Environmental Lawyers' request to meet with Administrator Pruitt, highlighting her appreciation for their efforts in facilitating this meeting. 2017 HQ2017008402 3
The email correspondence between EPA officials and the Domestic Energy Producers Alliance discusses scheduling a meeting with EPA Administrator Pruitt on September 28, 2017. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The document contains calendar invitations from Scott Cameron of the Department of the Interior for meetings with Amos Eno scheduled on September 20, 2017, and December 19, 2017. 2017 2
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Global Energy Institute, led by Sue Forrester, launched an "Energy Strong" video series showcasing the contributions of the energy industry during Hurricanes Harvey and Irma, specifically highlighting the rescue efforts of Golden Pass LNG employees. 2017
ED_002061_00150246
Christian Palich
2
The email discusses conservative groups urging the US International Trade Commission to reject a solar tariff petition by Suniva, citing concerns over increased costs and potential retaliation from trading partners, while also mentioning a press briefing on steel tariff issues. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 4
The email from Tate Bennett to Adam Piper discusses an embargoed signed letter from Arizona Governor Ducey related to the Sierra Club v. EPA case, indicating that they will notify once a press release is sent. 2017
ED_002061_00078227
Tate Bennett
1
The Bureau of Land Management officials, Steve Tryon and Karen Kelleher, are coordinating to review and edit a Google Doc related to their response on a matter designated as 3349. 2017 BLM201800412 3
The document consists of emails between Ryan Jackson, Chief of Staff at the EPA, and Terry Allen, discussing congratulations on Jackson's new job and potential future collaborations related to EPA clients. 2017 HQ2017008402 30
The email correspondence between EPA officials and Rebbie Riley from the American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers discusses the coordination of a meeting scheduled for June 14, 2017, at 3:30 p.m. regarding the Sierra Club v. EPA case. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 35
The email from Millan Hupp at the EPA discusses a scheduled meeting regarding the Sierra Club v. EPA case, indicating that Matthew will call upon arrival. 2017 1
The email from the EPA discusses the attendance of three CEOs from public power utilities at a CEO roundtable on June 19, highlighting their involvement in coal-fired generation and climate change policy, while also mentioning another potential attendee, Dan Sullivan. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 2
The email from Michael Abboud of the EPA discusses the status of the Risk Management Plan (RMP) rule and its amendments, clarifying that while the rule remains in effect, the major amendments finalized by the Obama administration would not take effect until March 2021, and emphasizing that existing safety requirements still applied to the Arkema Crosby plant during a fire incident. 2017
ED_002061_00031738
13 Tier
3
The Arizona Manufacturers Council hosted an event celebrating Manufacturing Day, where EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt announced the approval of Arizona's State Implementation Plan revision for visibility at the Coronado Generating Station, highlighting the Administration's efforts to reduce regulatory burdens on manufacturers while protecting the environment. 2017 1
The email exchange between Elizabeth Reicherts of Siemens Corporation and Troy Lyons of the EPA discusses coordinating a meeting and assistance related to the Sierra Club v. EPA case. 2017
ED_002061_00132655
Troy Lyons
3
The email correspondence between Michael Abboud from the EPA and Tom Thornton from S&P Global discusses scheduling a call regarding Scott Pruitt and the Annual Power and Gas Symposium. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 3
The email exchange between Tate Bennett from the EPA and Marvin Childers from The Poultry Federation discusses coordinating a meeting and dinner in Little Rock related to an upcoming event, with a mention of a protestor question. 2017
ED_002061_00077612
Tate Bennett
8
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced an extension of one year for states to submit initial area designations related to the 2015 National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for ozone, as communicated by Administrator Scott Pruitt in a letter to governors. 2017 EPA-HQ-2017-008402 4
The email correspondence involves the Environmental Protection Agency coordinating a meeting between Administrator Pruitt and the Board of Directors of Occidental Petroleum Corporation, with details about the meeting time and required documentation being discussed. 2017 3